I really like my friend’s justification in his fantasy worldbuilding, which explains it to my satisfaction:
When attempting to seal things of mundane power, mundane objects are sufficient, such as handcuffs and chains. When you try to seal something magically, that extra power needed to seal such a powerful entity has tradeoffs: the more magically unbreakable and irresistible you want the seal to be, the more fragile the conditions holding it must also be. Want to seal all the evils of the world, even for a short time? Well, looks like you’re going to need to store them in a top-heavy, ceramic jar with a tiny bottom, like Pandora’s Pithos. Trapping a genie? It’ll be much easier if you lay the trap with conditions for release, like someone rubbing it three times. Want to bind a violent spirit? Bind it to a fragile mirror, and make it so that she is freed if anyone stares into the mirror and says her name thrice, or if the mirror shatters.
This explains a lot of the folkloric sealing rituals in mythology.
Why don’t they ever put the items with the evil beings sealed in them in a heavy container with padding, then drop it into the middle of the ocean? It’s like they want them to be unsealed later for story purposes or something!
That’s only effective until the saltwater eats away at all of the seals, at which point it’s free again. Ancient vaults containing artifacts of fell power and their incumbent curses comprise one of the most popular adventure story archetypes. The point is, it’s only gone until someone stumbles across it, and now it’s _un_gone, and worse, the hapless stumbler has no idea what’s going on.
Imprisoning a powerful being in an oil lamp that can be released simply by someone rubbing it is a pretty shitty setup!
Decades of JRPG have taught me those seals on ancient evils are almost always made breakable by a dumb kid that has no idea what he’s doing.
Sealed Evil in a Can
You gotta warn someone before sending them down a TV Tropes rabbit hole!
wait shit the trope is actually called that?
I really like my friend’s justification in his fantasy worldbuilding, which explains it to my satisfaction:
When attempting to seal things of mundane power, mundane objects are sufficient, such as handcuffs and chains. When you try to seal something magically, that extra power needed to seal such a powerful entity has tradeoffs: the more magically unbreakable and irresistible you want the seal to be, the more fragile the conditions holding it must also be. Want to seal all the evils of the world, even for a short time? Well, looks like you’re going to need to store them in a top-heavy, ceramic jar with a tiny bottom, like Pandora’s Pithos. Trapping a genie? It’ll be much easier if you lay the trap with conditions for release, like someone rubbing it three times. Want to bind a violent spirit? Bind it to a fragile mirror, and make it so that she is freed if anyone stares into the mirror and says her name thrice, or if the mirror shatters.
This explains a lot of the folkloric sealing rituals in mythology.
Why don’t they ever put the items with the evil beings sealed in them in a heavy container with padding, then drop it into the middle of the ocean? It’s like they want them to be unsealed later for story purposes or something!
That’s only effective until the saltwater eats away at all of the seals, at which point it’s free again. Ancient vaults containing artifacts of fell power and their incumbent curses comprise one of the most popular adventure story archetypes. The point is, it’s only gone until someone stumbles across it, and now it’s _un_gone, and worse, the hapless stumbler has no idea what’s going on.
The bottom of the ocean is pretty inaccessible even if the container rusts away.
But that doesn’t stop the thing from getting out when the seal corrodes away…
If the container itself is flimsy enough to corrode away, escaping it is inevitable.
mystical sealing spells require the magic of plot contrivance
Agreed, but that was the only way we could do it. Sorta like a loophole the genie didn’t expect becuz it’s so dumb.
Trick it into obedience?
dammit iblis get back in your can